Skip to content Skip to navigation

'Like a Large Fleet Sailing Under Convoy'

April 7, 2009
by David Raths
| Reprints

It may not be immediately obvious how the problems that vexed the nation's founding fathers apply to the challenge of creating a national health information network. But perhaps because I live in Philadelphia and walk at night past Independence Hall, the words of the founders often strike me as relevant to our times.

For instance, on June 17, 1775, John Adams of Massachusetts wrote: "America is a great, unwieldy body. Its progress must be slow. It is like a large fleet sailing under convoy. The fleetest sailors must wait for the dullest and the slowest. Like a coach and six, the swiftest horses must be slackened, and the slowest quickened, that all may keep an even pace...."

This quote came back to me last week as I attended a webinar put on by Perot Systems' healthcare group about the impact of the Health Information Technology for Economic and Clinical Health Act (HITECH) provisions of ARRA.

Harry Greenspun, M.D., Perot's chief medical officer, noted that David Blumenthal, M.D., the new National Coordinator for Health Information Technology, has quite a challenge ahead of him in crafting the definition of meaningful use. He can't set the bar too low or the healthcare system's progress will be slowed, but he can't set it so high that nobody qualifies.

Like the colonists proposing independence, the health IT execs leading the effort have to find the right pace of change, financial help and encouragement so that the slowest adopters don't get frustrated and give up. Just as Adams needed all the colonies to agree to independence, Blumenthal needs all types of providers, large and small, to participate to make a true national network of interoperable health records. Perhaps this is where the proposed Regional Health IT Extension Centers will be key---in helping clinics and small practices find success with EHRs.

Dr. Greenspun and other Perot executives said their customers are eager to know what it will mean to comply. If they have 75 percent of orders going through CPOE, is that enough, or will it have to be 100 percent? Will they have to be actually exchanging data—or just show the capability to do so?

Also, many sophisticated hospitals in terms of health IT are academic medical centers that have built best-of-breed clinical information systems that are not yet certified. Will these systems that meet all the requirements but fail to get certified be punished? Will CCHIT (or whatever certifying body evolves) develop some way to accommodate certification of these systems?

Â

Topics

Comments

David,
Nice post. I've worked with Dr Harry Greenspun in the past. I agree. He's a delightfully clear and direct thinker.

Regarding CPOE utilization, I've always found it interesting how Gartner and Klas have covered this. Hopefully, Klas (specifically Yvonne Miller) will provide Dr Blumenthal with a briefing from their research. They could elaborate a very data informed, segment-specific report on utilization today. My understanding is that they called every hospital doing CPOE and followed-up in a statistical number of verification visits.

In reaction to Jim Feldbaum's comment regading 'those of us stuck at home,' we did something novel this year.

Most of my client contacts are, not surprisingly, physicians. On Wednesday with the show winding down, I tried an experiment. I provided a physician in Oklahoma a virtual booth visit using Skype. With a readily available, $100 Logitech auto-focus, high-res web cam, we successfully demonstrated voice-recognition and EMR integration, including live interoperability with another vendor, on an iPhone. I had to mention the iPhone to give you a sense of the size of the readable text and interface that came through smoothly over video conferencing.

I'm glad my friend Dr Danny Sands, CMO at Cisco, encouraged me to experience their telepresence demonstration at this HIMSS. I agree with Halamka's recent blogged observation. I'm paraphrasing here:

Sometimes video conferencing is not the next best thing to being there. It's better than being there.


(no business travel, and you can improve work/life balance, for example, be present for your daughter's birthday party!)

I continue to be intrigued by the slow adoption of this technology in business, with the concurrent rapid adoption in the consumer/family space. Interesting.

Kudos to all HIMSS reporters. Thanks for the updates. Those of us stuck at home look forward to each report.

David Raths

Contributing Editor

David Raths

@DavidRaths

www.linkedin.com/in/davidraths

David Raths’ blog focuses on health IT policy issues ranging from patient privacy to health...