Skip to content Skip to navigation

Report: No Correlation Between Hospital Proximity, Quality

September 15, 2016
by Rajiv Leventhal
| Reprints

Despite what patients may think, there are large differences in cost and quality among hospitals operating in the same regions, sometimes within just a few miles of each other, according to a new whitepaper from FairChex, a healthcare provider value measurement tool offered by Canada-based Global Excel Management.

FairChex’s quality ratings are based on an evaluation of the process of care, patient satisfaction and clinical outcomes. Quality data examines hospitals at the department/clinical category level, to avoid masking low-value departments operating within hospitals with higher values. Cost data examines hospitals at the procedure level based on diagnoses-related group (DRG) codes using the best available data on Medicare reimbursements (inpatient) and/or CPT codes for outpatient procedures, according to company officials.

The FairChex report, “Closest Hospital Is Rarely the Best Choice,” focuses on three common procedures in three different areas of the U.S.:

• Coronary bypass (New York)—Costs to Medicare for this procedure, the most commonly-performed heart surgery, vary by more than $20,000 between high-quality facilities located within New York City and several, such as St. Francis Hospital in Roslyn, NY, and Englewood Hospital and Medical Center in Englewood, N.J., that are within 25 miles of the city.

• Joint Replacement (San Francisco)—In contrast to New York City, patients in the Bay Area seeking more affordable treatment options need to go substantially inland for their procedures. However, within 100 miles of the San Francisco city center, three facilities in the Modesto-Stockton corridor offer high levels of quality and cost savings in excess of $5,000—potentially large savings for individuals with high co-insurance requirements.

• Mastectomy (Montana)—Unlike the first two case studies, Helena, MT, is not a densely-populated place. There is only one option for treatment within the city and it offers some of the lowest quality outcomes for this type of cancer care anywhere in the U.S. However, within 100 miles there are two other facilities that offer outstanding care (quality outcomes above the 80th percentile) at virtually the same price.

“The U.S. healthcare system has never provided patients the information on cost and quality needed to make informed decisions, which is why we continue to see tens of thousands of patients each year going to more expensive, lower-quality hospitals when there may be far better options operating virtually next door,” said Benjamin Tabah, managing director, FairChex.

The report notes that without objective data, patients “blindly” follow the recommendations of their primary physicians, their co-workers, or even billboards. These practices continue despite broad awareness that preventable hospital errors kill tens of thousands of people each year and that hospitals can charge very different prices for the same procedures.

“Across the U.S. healthcare system, one of the easiest ways to reduce costs would be to redirect patients from low-quality/high-cost facilities to high-quality/low-cost alternatives,” said Tabah. “In the short term, we could save $100 per year per person—or $25 billion annually—with that one simple switch. In the long term, the dynamic effects of competition on hospital leadership would lead to better quality and cost of care.”

Topics

Comments

I am actually surprised as I'm one of those people who'd just go to the nearest clinic. I think it's a good sign, it means that more people value their health and they're trying to get the best treatment possible.

Elizabeth

News

Two Republican Senators Unveil Proposed ACA Replacement Bill

Two Republican Senators, Bill Cassidy of Louisiana and Susan Collins of Maine, on Monday unveiled a proposed bill, called The Patient Freedom Act of 2017, that, rather than dismantling the Affordable Care Act (ACA), offered a partial replacement that would allow states to continue operating under the law if they choose.

Norris Cochran Tapped to Serve as Acting Secretary at HHS

Norris Cochran has been tapped to serve as Acting Secretary of the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) following the departure of former HHS Secretary Sylvia Burwell as part of the ongoing Trump Administration transition.

Consumers Increasingly Willing to Try Telehealth, New Survey Finds

About one in five consumers said they would switch their current primary care provider (PCP) if another PCP in their area offered telehealth visits, according to American Well’s latest survey.

New York Presbyterian Brooklyn Methodist Revalidated as EMRAM Stage 7

Due to its use of RFID technology to improve patient care and outcomes, New York Presbyterian Brooklyn Methodist Hospital (NYPBMH) has received acute care Stage 7 revalidation on the HIMSS Analytics Electronic Medical Record Adoption Model (EMRAM).

Dana Alexander Named 2016 HIMSS Nursing Informatics Leadership Award Winner

Dana Alexander, R.N., has been named the recipient of the 2016 HIMSS-ANI Nursing Informatics Leadership Award, a joint award sponsored by Alliance for Nursing Informatics (ANI) and HIMSS.

Agency Leadership Update: Collins Stays at NIH, Bindman Leaves AHRQ

As President-elect Donald Trump is sworn in as the United States’ 45th president at noon today, there has been an ongoing administration shuffle as agency leaders have stepped down as part of the presidential transition.