Market Profile: A MediCal Managed Care Perspective on the Challenges and Opportunities Facing San Diegans | Healthcare Informatics Magazine | Health IT | Information Technology Skip to content Skip to navigation

Market Profile: A MediCal Managed Care Perspective on the Challenges and Opportunities Facing San Diegans

January 2, 2018
by Mark Hagland
| Reprints
Community Health Group’s Joseph Garcia shares his perspectives on the San Diego managed care market

In previous installments in this series of articles on the San Diego healthcare market, we looked at such important topics as the decades-long history of collaboration among stakeholder groups in that metropolitan area, and the challenges and opportunities involved in moving ahead on population health management and care management in that market.

In this installment of the series, we look at the health plan perspective on the San Diego metro market. For this article, Healthcare Informatics Editor-in-Chief Mark Hagland spoke this past autumn to Joseph Garcia, COO of Community Health Group, to get a community health plan-based perspective on the challenges and opportunities facing the metropolitan San Diego healthcare market.

Community Health Group (CHG), is a local health plan with 290,000 members, 280,000 of whom are MediCal (California’s version of Medicaid) members. Community Health Plan actually started out as a federally qualified health center (FQHC) decades ago, and its leaders remain committed to sticking close to their community. Garcia’s perspective is also enriched by the fact that “We work with practically every primary care physician in San Diego County” outside the Kaiser and Sharp HealthCare organizations, as he notes.

As mentioned in the first article in this series, CHG has been participating in a county-wide effort, led by the county’s health department, to control and end an outbreak of hepatitis A that has caused many problems and been difficult to control, especially given a very large homeless and transient population in the county. More broadly, CHG has been working collaboratively with providers for its entire existence. Below are excerpts from Hagland’s interview with Garcia.

How many providers do you work with in the San Diego metropolitan area?

We work with practically every primary care physician in San Diego County, and with most specialists. Kaiser and Sharp don’t contract with us, but nearly everybody else does; 95 percent outside those groups don’t.

What is the operational and care management landscape like for you and your colleagues, at a health plan that is 95-percent MediCal (Medicaid in other states)?

I’ve been here 30 years, and we’ve been here for over 30 years, and I have a very good historical perspective. And the message we have for our staff is, treat our members as they were your own loved ones. That’s our goal, and that’s held us in good stead all this time. And a key reason for our market presence is our commitment to customer service. We bend over backwards to provide service. We answer 90 percent of the calls to our customer service center within 10 seconds, and it’s a real, live person, 24/7, all year long. That’s a financial and operational commitment on our part.

What has it been like working with providers in San Diego County?

This is the only county we’re in; and every provider knows our corporate headquarters is right here, and they can meet with the CEO, COO, CMO—they can come over or call. We have 30-year relationships. We were born out of a community health center, San Isidro Health Center. We were a provider, then a provider and health plan together, and then 20 years ago, we separated. And I and others have worked at both. So we understand the doctors, and the stresses that they face in doing their jobs, and they know that we understand. San Isidro is one of the top-three largest FQHCs in San Diego County.

What have been the biggest challenges and opportunities in pursuing population health management strategies, for you and your colleagues?

The biggest challenge is that trying to change individuals’ behavior is the most difficult thing. Most plan members with chronic conditions have two, three or four of them: asthma, diabetes, COPD [chronic obstructive pulmonary disease], CHF [congestive health failure], hypertension, obesity. And if you know that you have hypertension, and eat a lot of salt, you know that’s a problem. The same thing is true with not taking the medication if you’re diabetic. And the reality is that our own staff face challenges themselves in terms of not always doing what they’re supposed to do. Maybe they don’t because it’s hard, or because they just don’t do it; but it’s that much harder for MediCal patients, because it’s very hard to initiate behavioral changes; but it’s a lot cheaper to go to McDonald’s and buy cheap food that’s not as healthy, as to cook healthily. And the issue is one of finances.

Could you mention one or two advances that you and your colleagues have been able to make recently?

One of the areas we’re very proud of us around our HEDIS [Healthcare Effectiveness Data and Information Set] scores. For the past ten years, we’ve pretty much been able to improve our HEDIS scores year over year. And those scores are used to determine whether a health plan is delivering quality care. And one or two years, we’ve been number one in the state, and nearly every year, we’re in the top five to seven. We’re nearly always in the top tier in terms of making sure the care we provide our members, is on the higher end of that spectrum.

Tell me a bit about how you and your colleagues have been using data, IT, and analytics, to help with your work?


Get the latest information on Health IT and attend other valuable sessions at this two-day Summit providing healthcare leaders with educational content, insightful debate and dialogue on the future of healthcare and technology.

Learn More