And Then There's That Chinese Proverb | Mark Hagland | Healthcare Blogs Skip to content Skip to navigation

And Then There's That Chinese Proverb

October 27, 2010
| Reprints
It is indeed the curse of interesting times, for physicians

MGMA president and CEO William Jessee, M.D., referenced the old Chinese proverb in his remarks at the press briefing here in New Orleans on Monday. It's that proverb that says, "May you be cursed to live in interesting times." Dr. Jessee certainly is right that these are very "interesting" times for physicians. Buffeted by actual and anticipated reimbursement cuts for Medicare, expected to achieve meaningful use under HITECH, and facing both potentially excellent and destabilizing effects from the implementation of federal healthcare reform, doctors are feeling "tempest-toss'd" as never before.

All that has been clearly on display this year at the MGMA annual conference. While there are numerous opportunities emerging in the field, including the chance to help create the new reality of accountable care organizations and bundled payments (not to mention the raft of newly insured patients expected to knock on their doors over the next few years), physician group leaders are deeply concerned over the instability of Medicare reimbursement, the unknowns around the new payment models, and, based on recent MGMA membership surveys, a tremendous hesitancy on the part of many member physician organizations to leap head-first into EMR adoption in the currently unsettled environment.

Given the potentially dramatic cuts in physician reimbursement coming out of developments around the sustainable growth rate (SGR) under Medicare that could hit doctors at year's end, perhaps it shouldn't be surprising that medical groups are hesitating significantly around EMR implementation right now. Indeed, MGMA's recent survey finding that 45.3 percent of medical groups "will likely" delay EMR implementation if the full SGR cuts go into place in January, should be seen as alarming on numerous levels.

But can one blame doctors in this situation? If they see up to a combined 30 percent pay cut under Medicare, it could be devastating for many. Naturally,that reimbursement change would undermine the goals of physician EMR adoption under HITECH. Indeed, Dr. Jessee spoke to Dr. David Blumenthal about that very issue in a conversation on Monday, Jessee told me in our exclusive interview.

Alas, as so often happens in the policy world, there are inevitably cognitive dissonances that arise between two different policy imperatives, in this case, the need to rein in Medicare costs, and the need to promote automation in patient care. But it would be devastating for HITECH if very large numbers of physicians gave up on EMR adoption because of Medicare cuts. Thus, the SGR/meaningful use "cross-tab" has emerged as one of the Rubik's cube-like issues most discussed at this year's MGMA conference, and for good reason.

One thing that hospital and health system CIOs in particular will need to remain highly conscious of is of that particular stressor in the physician world, as it holds tremendous implications for physician end-user automation and EMR adoption, interoperability, health information exchange, and a host of other areas. It will be fascinating to see how all this turns out, and what the most challenging issues are at MGMA one year from now, when medical group leaders reconvene next October in Las Vegas.

The Health IT Summits gather 250+ healthcare leaders in cities across the U.S. to present important new insights, collaborate on ideas, and to have a little fun - Find a Summit Near You!


See more on