Study: Competition Thwarting E-Data Exchange | Healthcare Informatics Magazine | Health IT | Information Technology Skip to content Skip to navigation

Study: Competition Thwarting E-Data Exchange

February 25, 2008
by root
| Reprints

Barriers to sharing clinical data electronically among rival hospitals, doctors and health plans remain high as concerns about loss of competitive advantage and data misuse hamper participation in local health information exchanges, according to a study by the Center for Studying Health System Change (HSC) and the National Institute for Health Care Management (NIHCM) Foundation.

According to the study, the more mature exchanges — Cincinnati-based HealthBridge and the Indiana Health Information Exchange (IHIE) based in Indianapolis — have achieved “some viability” by meeting a specific business need for more efficient delivery of hospital test results to physicians. The newer exchanges — CareSpark, serving northeast Tennessee and southwest Virginia, and the Tampa Bay Regional Health Information Organization (RHIO) — have struggled to identify and finance initial services without a similar critical mass of hospital participation, according to the study.

The study’s findings are detailed in a new HSC-NIHCM Research Brief, “Creating Sustainable Local Health Information Exchanges: Can Barriers to Stakeholder Participation Be Overcome?” available online at

The study found that provider organizations still face substantial disincentives to share data with unaffiliated organizations. Beyond the hospital systems in Cincinnati and Indianapolis, stakeholders were unwilling to pay enough collectively for the same set of services to sustain HIEs. Generally, neither health plans nor employers were willing to fund core clinical data exchange as a benefit for patients. Employers typically also did not see themselves funding HIEs to support quality initiatives, and health plans had few incentives to deviate from company-wide pay-for-performance strategies to participate in local efforts, the study found.

Get the latest information on Health IT and attend other valuable sessions at this two-day Summit providing healthcare leaders with educational content, insightful debate and dialogue on the future of healthcare and technology.

Learn More



Sounds like Ammo for the DEMS to a launch a SINGLE PAYOR system and leave these GREEDY players holding the bag and woudn't THAT be a Nice!

This is a battle between fragmented healthcare institutions. The U.S. needs to reinforce the first front-line of preventative medicine with their selected primary care physician in the clinic environment.

The real problem before overcoming the barriers to legitimately sharing the patients electronic medical record, is the efficient compiling of a complete patient EMR itself. The patient's medical record belongs to the patient and with their ed primary care physician(s) in the clinic where the patient encounter routinely occurs. This includes all private practice clinic facilities however large or small wherever the patient and their clinic resides. Diagnostic procedure reports (lab test, imaging, consulting specialists, etc.) outside the primary care clinic needs to be compiled back to the patient's primary care clinic as the patient's primary data repository.


NIH Issues Funding Announcement for All of Us Genomic Research Program

The National Institutes of Health’s (NIH) “All of Us” Research Program has issued a funding announcement for genome centers to generate genotype and whole genome sequence data from participants’ biosamples.

MGMA: Physician Compensation Data Illustrates Nationwide PCP Shortage

Primary care physicians’ compensation rose by more than 10 percent over the past five years, representing an increase which is nearly double that of specialty physicians’ compensation over the same period, according to the Medical Group Management Association (MGMA).

Circulation, Buoy Health Collaborate on Integrated Platform for Patient Transportation

Boston-based startup Circulation Health, a ride-ordering exchange that coordinates medical transportation logistics using Lyft and other transportation partners, is partnering with Buoy Health, also based in Boston, to integrate their platforms to provide patients with an end-to-end healthcare experience.

HITRUST Provides NIST Cybersecurity Framework Certification

The Health Information Trust Alliance (HITRUST), security and privacy standards development and accreditation organization, announced this week a certification program for the National Institute of Standards and Technology's (NIST) Cybersecurity Framework (Framework).

Report: Interoperability in NHS England Faces Similar Barriers as U.S. Healthcare

Electronic patient record interoperability in NHS England is benefiting patient care, but interoperability efforts are facing barriers, including limited data sharing and cumbersome processes falling outside of the clinician workflow, according to a KLAS Research report.

Geisinger National Precision Health Hires Illumina Exec to Lead Business Development

Integrated health system Geisinger has hired a high-profile genetic counselor to head up business development for Geisinger National Precision Health, which was created to extend the Geisinger model on the national scene.