Supreme Court Rules that Providers Cannot Sue States Over Medicaid Payment | Healthcare Informatics Magazine | Health IT | Information Technology Skip to content Skip to navigation

Supreme Court Rules that Providers Cannot Sue States Over Medicaid Payment

March 31, 2015
by Mark Hagland
| Reprints
The U.S. Supreme Court rules against providers in lawsuits over Medicaid reimbursement

On Tuesday morning, March 31, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled in Armstrong et al v. Exceptional Child Center, Inc., et al, that private healthcare providers cannot sue states over low Medicaid reimbursement rates, in a 5-4 ruling, reversing a lower court’s ruling. Providers had argued that suing over low rates is sometimes the only way to enforce federal payment requirements.  But their opponents asserted that a ruling in favor of providers could lead to unending litigation that would slow the system.

The Supreme Court took up the case after Idaho residential providers for disabled patients sued state officials over that state’s failure to implement higher reimbursement rates, after the Idaho Legislature failed to sufficiently fund such reimbursement. A federal district court ruled that Idaho’s rates did not align with requirements in federal law requiring adequate reimbursement, and the distrct court was upheld by the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals.

A report in the online news service NewsMax reported that  “State officials recommended increases in reimbursement rates in the late 2000s but they were never implemented because the Idaho legislature declined to appropriate funds, according to court papers.Writing on behalf of the majority,” the NewsMax report said, “Justice Antonin Scalia said that the providers have no right to sue the state under the so-called Supremacy Clause of the U.S. Constitution, which holds that federal law generally trumps state law. The clause ‘instructs courts what to do when state and federal law clash, but is silent regarding who may enforce federal laws in court,’ Scalia wrote.”

The report further said that “Scalia noted that the providers have another option: they can ask the federal government to intervene on their behalf. In a dissenting opinion, Justice Sonia Sotomayor said there was nothing in the Medicaid law to suggest that Congress intended to prevent private lawsuits.”

 

 

Topics

News

NewYork-Presbyterian, Walgreens Partner on Telemedicine Initiative

NewYork-Presbyterian and Walgreens are collaborating to bring expanded access to NewYork-Presbyterian’s healthcare through new telemedicine services, the two organizations announced this week.

ONC Releases Patient Demographic Data Quality Framework

The Office of the National Coordinator for Health IT (ONC) developed a framework to help health systems, large practices, health information exchanges and payers to improve their patient demographic data quality.

AMIA, Pew Urge Congress to Ensure ONC has Funding to Implement Cures Provisions

The Pew Charitable Trusts and the American Medical Informatics Association (AMIA) have sent a letter to congressional appropriators urging them to ensure that ONC has adequate funding to implement certain 21st Century Cures Act provisions.

Former Michigan Governor to Serve as Chair of DRIVE Health

Former Michigan Governor John Engler will serve as chair of the DRIVE Health Initiative, a campaign aimed at accelerating the U.S. health system's transition to value-based care.

NJ Medical Group Launches Statewide HIE, OneHealth New Jersey

The Medical Society of New Jersey (MSNJ) recently launched OneHealth New Jersey, a statewide health information exchange (HIE) that is now live.

Survey: 70% of Providers Using Off-Premises Computing for Some Applications

A survey conducted by KLAS Research found that 70 percent of healthcare organizations have moved at least some applications or IT infrastructure off-premises.