Study: Socioeconomic Digital Divide Remains in Personal Health Record Use | Healthcare Informatics Magazine | Health IT | Information Technology Skip to content Skip to navigation

Study: Socioeconomic Digital Divide Remains in Personal Health Record Use

August 19, 2016
by Heather Landi
| Reprints

More patients are using personal health records (PHRs), yet there are socioeconomics disparities in the adoption of PHRs and patient portals to access health records, according to a study published in the American Journal of Managed Care.

Researchers from the Department of Healthcare Policy and Research at Weill Cornell Medical College examined the rate of public adoption of health IT by accessing portal/PHR use. The researchers contend that the use of PHRs and electronic patient portals, referred to as “tethered PHRs,” has increased due to the Federal Electronic Health Record (EHR) incentive program, or Meaningful Use. Since 2010, Meaningful Use has been incentivizing healthcare providers and hospitals to adopt EHRs, and In turn, providers are required to make electronic data available to patients.

According to the researchers, early studies have indicated that patients in disadvantaged socioeconomic groups were less likely to use health IT to access their health records. There is concern that this “digital divide” prevents the neediest patients from benefitting from health IT, the study authors wrote.

The researchers utilized the Empire State Poll, a survey of 900 New York state residents about health services, including health IT. For the study, researchers looked at responses for the poll each year from 2012 to 2015.

The survey respondents were specifically asked about their use of PHRs or patient portals in order to obtain, keep or update their health information.

The study findings indicated that rates of personal health record use increased rapidly across the board, from 11 percent in 2012 to 27.1 percent in 2015. 

And, researchers noted that initially black respondents were substantially less likely to use portals/PHRs than white respondents. In the 2012 survey, only 4.3 percent of black respondents used PHRs or patient portals, however that percentage rose sharply to 23.9 percent in 2015.

“By 2015, the proportion of blacks who used portals/PHRs was not significantly different from the proportion of other races,” the study authors wrote, comparing the 23.9 percent of black respondents to the 28.1 percent of white respondents.

However, the researchers did notice disparities in PHR adoption among individuals of Hispanic ethnicity. While in 2012, the PHR adoption rate among Hispanics was not significantly lower than the rate among non-Hispanics at 9 percent versus 11 percent, by 2015, despite an increase, the adoption rate lagged significantly. The rate of adoption among respondents of Hispanic ethnicity increased to 15.8 percent by 2015, compared to 29.3 percent of non-Hispanic respondents.

The study authors also found that while adoption rate of PHRs/portals among low-income respondents, or respondents whose household income was less than $50,000, rose between 2012 and 2015, the adoption rate remained about half the rate reported by higher-income respondents. In 2012, the low-income demographic had an adoption rate of 7.2 percent and that rose to only 18.2 percent by 2015, compared to 32.6 percent of higher-income respondents.

“As previously reported, the use of portals/PHRs was also more common among patients who used the Internet more frequently, those with higher education, and those using prescription medications,” the study authors wrote.

The good news, according to the study authors, during the four-year period in which federal policies incentivized healthcare providers to give medical record access to patients through PHRs and electronic portals, the percentage of New Yorkers using these technologies more than doubled. “Racial disparities in technology adoption largely disappeared during this time,” the study authors wrote.

However, the study authors also concluded that there continues to be a digital divide on the basis of income and Hispanic ethnicity.

As electronic patient portals and PHRs are anticipated to be a critical tool for patient engagement, it is important for healthcare providers to determine whether they are reaching all patient populations, the study authors wrote.

Healthcare organizations using these health IT tools to engage patients need to examine their efforts to reach all patient groups, especially low-income and Hispanic patients, who seem less likely to use the technology, according to the study findings.

“Measures that should be investigated include making these technologies accessible in multiple languages, designing for usability by individuals with low levels of computer expertise and ensuring access via mobile phone and web browsers,” the study authors concluded.

Get the latest information on Meaningful Use and attend other valuable sessions at this two-day Summit providing healthcare leaders with educational content, insightful debate and dialogue on the future of healthcare and technology.

Learn More



Community Data Sharing: Eight Recommendations From San Diego

A learning guide focuses on San Diego’s experience in building a community health information exchange and the realities of embarking on a broad community collaboration to achieve better data sharing.

HealthlinkNY’s Galanis to Step Down as CEO

Christina Galanis, who has served as president and CEO of HealthlinkNY for the past 13 years, will leave her position at the end of the year.

Email-Related Cyber Attacks a Top Concern for Providers

U.S. healthcare providers overwhelmingly rank email as the top source of a potential data breach, according to new research from email and data security company Mimecast and conducted by HIMSS Analytics.

Former Health IT Head in San Diego County Charged with Defrauding Provider out of $800K

The ex-health IT director at North County Health Services, a San Diego County-based healthcare service provider, has been charged with spearheading fraudulent operations that cost the organization $800,000.

Allscripts Touts 1 Billion API Shares in 2017

Officials from Chicago-based health IT vendor Allscripts have attested that the company has reached a new milestone— one billion application programming interface (API) data exchange transactions in 2017.

Dignity Health, CHI Merging to Form New Catholic Health System

Catholic Health Initiatives (CHI), based in Englewood, Colorado, and San Francisco-based Dignity Health officially announced they are merging and have signed a definitive agreement to combine ministries and create a new, nonprofit Catholic health system.